I have a question: have you heard of the homeschool co-op "classical conversations" and what do you think of it? Would you think it to be fine if one highly valued and practiced CM philosophy and tried to implement this in their academics? This is something I am struggling and praying through as a young homeschool mom. I would really appreciate your insight.
Kevin and Tara, I firmly believe that requiring intensive memorization of large amounts of historic facts is diametrically opposed to a Charlotte Mason education. We are trying to fill our children's minds with satisfying, worthy, thought-provoking IDEAS that grab the spirit and motivate the child to learn more, to act upon what he has heard through everyday play and imagination, to aspire to think and do great deeds.
Meaningless, rote memorization stuffed into a child's mind who only cares to memorize it for the outer praise and rewards received from parent, peers and teachers does not accomplish a love of learning for the right reasons. One of the arguments I have heard in favor of this method is 'it doesn't matter if the child doesn't understand what he is memorizing. He will care about the info later, just fill his mind with the info now because he has the capacity to memorize a lot of facts while young...' This saddens me. Children deserve better. Miss Mason believed that children are spiritual beings who crave meaningful ideas and can handle them just fine.
Here's another parent's perspective: http://a-large-room.blogspot.com/2009/02/homeschool-resource-review-classical.html
Beautiful and Unique Gift Ideas Calligraphy, illumination, illustration and original artwork celebrating literary masterpieces and what they mean for the great battle of our time.
New Release
Collected Poems written by Charlotte Mason graduate Bryana Johnson Now available in paperback and KINDLE
"Bryana Johnson's first collection of poetry establishes her as a Christian poet who communicates the gutsy, bleeding beat of life and death...restoring our confidence that there are poets who labor over the word, and who have something to say that the world needs to hear."
- Nathan Harms, Director, Utmost Christian Writers Foundation
"These poems are works of elegance...In a voice both compassionate and compelling, Bryana presents her readers with works that examine what it means to be human and how our very faults and foibles can, in the end, become instruments of grace."
- Wendy Galgan, editor of Assisi
“Then he breathed upon me and took away the trembling from my limbs and caused me to stand upon my feet. And after that, he said not much, but that we should meet again, and I must go further up and further in. Then he turned him about in a storm and flurry of gold and was gone suddenly.
And since then, O Kings and Ladies, I have been wandering to find him and my happiness is so great that it even weakens me like a wound. And this is the marvel of marvels, that he called me Beloved, me who am but as a dog-”
The Last Battle, C.S. Lewis
Oooooo...thank you!!! I *just* was talking to my sister today about this very topic!
ReplyDeleteYes...you said it best!
ReplyDeleteI have a question: have you heard of the homeschool co-op "classical conversations" and what do you think of it? Would you think it to be fine if one highly valued and practiced CM philosophy and tried to implement this in their academics? This is something I am struggling and praying through as a young homeschool mom. I would really appreciate your insight.
ReplyDeleteKevin and Tara,
ReplyDeleteI firmly believe that requiring intensive memorization of large amounts of historic facts is diametrically opposed to a Charlotte Mason education. We are trying to fill our children's minds with satisfying, worthy, thought-provoking IDEAS that grab the spirit and motivate the child to learn more, to act upon what he has heard through everyday play and imagination, to aspire to think and do great deeds.
Meaningless, rote memorization stuffed into a child's mind who only cares to memorize it for the outer praise and rewards received from parent, peers and teachers does not accomplish a love of learning for the right reasons. One of the arguments I have heard in favor of this method is 'it doesn't matter if the child doesn't understand what he is memorizing. He will care about the info later, just fill his mind with the info now because he has the capacity to memorize a lot of facts while young...' This saddens me. Children deserve better. Miss Mason believed that children are spiritual beings who crave meaningful ideas and can handle them just fine.
Here's another parent's perspective:
http://a-large-room.blogspot.com/2009/02/homeschool-resource-review-classical.html
hth,
lindafay