Thanks for posting this article on classical education. I agree, not just in theory but in practice. I am planning my son's high school curriculum and I want to stick with TWTM but I have had a hard time convincing myself that he is cut out for a "great books" study. I decided to start now and plan out what I want him to read and then do it myself to see what I thought. I started with Gilgamesh and now the Iliad. I have switched gears after completing those two books and I have realized that they may be great literature to some but unless I make them relavant to our Bible based teachings, they are just exercises and he will not be gaining any wisdom and understanding from them. Sure we could just read them through but it is worthless if we don't actually gain something from them.
I am printing the article out and saving it for those days where I need to remind myself of the "why's" of a classical education.
Barb Harmony Art Mom
• Permanent Link
November 11, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by lindafay
I agree with you. I remember reading that David Hicks realized over time that he had once placed too much value in the early ancient documents. He still thinks they are valuable, but not as he supposed. I think it is helpful to remember that early classical students read the ancient works exclusively because their choices were limited. We now have a much larger banquet to choose from.
Beautiful and Unique Gift Ideas Calligraphy, illumination, illustration and original artwork celebrating literary masterpieces and what they mean for the great battle of our time.
New Release
Collected Poems written by Charlotte Mason graduate Bryana Johnson Now available in paperback and KINDLE
"Bryana Johnson's first collection of poetry establishes her as a Christian poet who communicates the gutsy, bleeding beat of life and death...restoring our confidence that there are poets who labor over the word, and who have something to say that the world needs to hear."
- Nathan Harms, Director, Utmost Christian Writers Foundation
"These poems are works of elegance...In a voice both compassionate and compelling, Bryana presents her readers with works that examine what it means to be human and how our very faults and foibles can, in the end, become instruments of grace."
- Wendy Galgan, editor of Assisi
“Then he breathed upon me and took away the trembling from my limbs and caused me to stand upon my feet. And after that, he said not much, but that we should meet again, and I must go further up and further in. Then he turned him about in a storm and flurry of gold and was gone suddenly.
And since then, O Kings and Ladies, I have been wandering to find him and my happiness is so great that it even weakens me like a wound. And this is the marvel of marvels, that he called me Beloved, me who am but as a dog-”
The Last Battle, C.S. Lewis
November 8, 2006 - Amen
ReplyDeletePosted by HarmonyArtMom
Lindafay,
Thanks for posting this article on classical education. I agree, not just in theory but in practice. I am planning my son's high school curriculum and I want to stick with TWTM but I have had a hard time convincing myself that he is cut out for a "great books" study. I decided to start now and plan out what I want him to read and then do it myself to see what I thought. I started with Gilgamesh and now the Iliad. I have switched gears after completing those two books and I have realized that they may be great literature to some but unless I make them relavant to our Bible based teachings, they are just exercises and he will not be gaining any wisdom and understanding from them. Sure we could just read them through but it is worthless if we don't actually gain something from them.
I am printing the article out and saving it for those days where I need to remind myself of the "why's" of a classical education.
Barb
Harmony Art Mom
• Permanent Link
November 11, 2006 - Untitled Comment
Posted by lindafay
I agree with you.
I remember reading that David Hicks realized over time that he had once placed too much value in the early ancient documents. He still thinks they are valuable, but not as he supposed.
I think it is helpful to remember that early classical students read the ancient works exclusively because their choices were limited. We now have a much larger banquet to choose from.
• Permanent Link