Monday, February 18, 2008

Shakespeare Movies for the Family

When a creative work clearly reveals the common struggles that all humans face, it is able to stand the test of time. Shakespeare goes even further, showing the natural consequences of our choices. This, I believe, is an important reason why the writings of Shakespeare remain timeless classics and thus, are worthy to pass on to future generations.

The plays, however, were not performed for children, but rather adults. Does this mean a child shouldn't be exposed to them? I think most of us would say, 'not without some omissions.' Isn't that what we do with the Bible? After all, it contains many disturbing themes such as adultery, sibling rivalry, witchcraft, graphic murder and the like but we edit it for our young children so that they are at least exposed to suitable parts because we want to familiarize them with the storyline, realizing that this exposure prepares them to understand the deeper issues when they are introduced to the Bible in its entirety at a later stage. In other words, in spite of the mature themes, it is worthy. I would never equate Shakespeare's plays with the content in the Bible, but nevertheless, I believe the same principles apply because Shakespeare is worthy. It it helpful to introduce it to our children with edited versions so that later they will be ready to further appreciate and think upon ideas that all humans have in common. There are other excellent reasons but that is not the focus of this post. You can read more about this in a previous post and also in Rev. Ralph Smith's excellent article . Here is an enthusiastic introduction to Shakespeare for parents and high schoolers.

That said, I believe that you should find edited versions of Shakespeare movies if you have younger children. A picture often plays more powerfully upon the mind of a child than the written word, so we tread on dangerous ground. Personally, we have avoided watching the movies as a family but let our older children, around 10 yrs of age, begin watching the comedies that have been tastefully done. My teenagers have begun to study the tragedies and histories. That is why I am gathering a list of suitable movies from those who have gone before us.

The following list includes suggestions from my own personal experiences and also from previous commenters, online forums, and a book I own and recommend called Brightest Heaven of Invention. I did not include recommendations from those who had not watched the particular movie they suggested. I also did not include suggestions with vague reference points, for we need specific titles and versions. The ratings were derived from all the sources and determined by the general consensus,not necessarily what is printed on the DVD box. I hope that every parent and teacher previews EVERY Shakespeare movie before they allow child viewings, regardless of G ratings given by others. (I do this with ALL movies in our household, including renderings of the Biblical tales) So, without further ado, here is the list….

WELL KNOWN COMEDIES

As You Like It
Laurence Olivier (1936) "a cute, sweet, funny version." G rating

BBC version starring Helen Mirren. G rating

A Midsummer Night's Dream
(1935) with Mickey Rooney and James Cagney "funny and whimsical. The king of the fairies is a little scary-- we weren't sure why he was dressed so like the devil. His henchman are dressed like bats. But they don't come into it much." G rating

Film produced by Joseph Papp. G rating

1999 film starring Kevin Klein & Michelle Pfieffer, PG 13 rating

1968 Royal Shakespeare Company version -nudity, Not recommended for children.

Shakespeare for Kidz (for those in the UK)

Much Ado About Nothing
(1993) with Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson. "We greatly enjoyed it. (gratuitous nudity, the other with strongly implied fornication which is merely hinted at in the play)." PG 13 rating

Twelfth Night
The Thames Shakespeare project - "a filming of the actual play, good." G rating

The Taming of the Shrew

Starring Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor "well done" "some bawdy parts may need to be fast forwarded for younger viewers" PG rating

A Winter's Tale
Royal Shakespeare Company w/Sir Antony Sher. "Excellent", but "rude, obscene scene during the sheep shearing party that we fast-forwarded." PG rating

Merchant of Venice
BBC version with Warren Mitchell & Gemma Jones. "It was very tasteful in Elizabethan costume." G rating

Al Pacino, Jeremy Irons. "Excellent version for adults....female frontal above the waist nudity and sexual situations (brief) I love this version and fast forward through the few seconds of nudity to enjoy the richness of this movie and story." R rating

HISTORIES AND TRAGEDIES

Richard III
Laurence Olivier (1955) "was very good, but had some rough scenes for sensitive souls." PG rating

http://www.berith.org/hsres/shak/shak06.html has further comments on various movie versions of Richard III. Excellent source.

Hamlet
Laurence Olivier (1948) "Excellent. Ophelia's death scene and funeral were very tragic, and, again, rough for sensitive souls." "a little dated" PG rating

By Franco Zefferelli starring Mel Gibson. "There is a Freudian interpretation of the play and *not* appropriate for children (although it went over all our heads a few times!); can fast forward." PG rating

Henry V
Kenneth Branagh's version. "Sweet courting scene at the end between him and Emma Thompson." "The battle scenes are quite realistic, and in slow motion. Plus, it is the young boys, not the men, that get slaughtered by the French." PG rating, possibly PG-13 rating for sensitive viewers.

Starring Lawrence Olivier (1945), "excellent" PG rating

Julius Caesar
By Joseph Mankiewicz (1953) "One of the very best." Not rated

Starring Charlton Heston. Good. "Nothing objectionable." G rating

Macbeth
Orson Welles (1948) "nothing objectionable" but the theme is geared for older audiences, PG rating

Romeo & Juliet
CBC production starring Meagan Follows (from Anne of Green Gables). PG 13 rating

It seems to be the general consensus that BBC versions are almost always suitable for family viewing but more enjoyable for older students who are used to Shakespearean language. The plays are unedited, using the old language. At about 10 years of age plus, my children enjoyed viewing these while following along with a book. Unfortunately, they are expensive to purchase, but renting the movies are a good option. We've also enjoyed some of the free online and edited versions hosted at Ohio University. Shakespeare: The Animated Tales are nice edited versions for young children.

You can find most of the above recommendations at My Lil' Bookstore.

I hope this information has been helpful for some of you. I know it has helped me to put it all together in one place. I will add to this list as I find new information.


one step at a time...

16 comments:

  1. Thank you for this list. We are reading When Children Love to Learn in our Charlotte Mason support group and we will be covering the Shakespeare section next month. I'm going to print this list and pass it out to everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for compiling this list. I'm sure it will be helpful to many.

    Stacy

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, I'm glad to hear there's another good Macbeth out there. Maybe I can talk my husband into watching it. He watched the first half-hour or so of the RSC's one (with Ian McKellan) and was too bored by it to watch the rest. Well done and not objectionable, but definitely focused on words, not actions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is a wonderful post!
    I plan on checking out some of these.
    Recently we attempted to watch Orson Welles' "Macbeth".
    The kids asked to go to bed!
    It was pretty gloomy and bleak for kids under ten years.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous19.2.08

    Thank you for taking the time to post this. My oldest is 6 so we're just getting started w/Nesbit's Beautiful Tales of Shakespeare for Children, but I'll have to check out the animated version you mentioned, plus make a mental note to check your archives in a few year!

    Hope that you're feeling a bit more settled in TX!
    Thanks again,
    Luci

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the comprehensive list! I'm off to Netflix!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for this thorough list! I plan on checking several of these films out with my children.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow... I haven't read or watched any of Shakespeare's works. We do have a Midsummmer's Night Dream though that I may pick up and read. Mom said she enjoyed reading it when she was in school. lol! : )

    Love
    Jocelyn

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Linda!
    How is Texas? Is it warm there yet?

    I wanted to let you know that I tagged you for the middle name meme. You won't hurt my feelings if you don't want to participate!

    Blessings,
    Kim

    ReplyDelete
  10. We watched two good ones this weekend. Come see...
    http://www.homeschoolblogger.com/Keri/486857/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Another helpful post. This morning, after reading Kidnapped (which we do together), Ellie,9, asked to finish the story of Psyche and Cupid that we had begun last week. Usually, we do Age of Fable on Thursdays, but who am I to turn down a request like that? Especially when we nearly tossed the book out the door after a few exasperating readings at the beginning of our school year. I had written to you with my frustration, and you, wholeheartedly, recommended staying the course and gave some suggestions to try. Well, except for one or two of the more challenging readings, this has become a book looked forward to rather than one that is dreaded. Thank you so much for the encouragement. I hope that you are feeling more settled in the states as time goes on.

    Sarah

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you so much for this well-researched list of movies. I added your link to my Shakespeare For Children article.

    Over time, my family is enjoying learning about Shakespeare's world and seeing different adaptations of his plays. This is truly a life-long learner's project!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Lindafay,

    Can I link to this entry from the next edition of the blog carnival? There is going to be another post about Shakespeare and I would love to couple it with this fantastic list that you have compiled.

    Please submit let me know if you are agreeable. :)

    Thanks,
    Barb-Harmony Art Mom
    harmonyfinearts@yahoo.com

    ReplyDelete
  14. Making a note to refer back to this in the coming homeschool year. :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Gold’s proficiency with the camera and the lining up of shots, as well as his obvious knowledge of Shakespeare (this is not the only BBC Shakespeare series he did), are paramount here.
    http://postmoderndeconstructionmadhouse.blogspot.com/2014/06/macbeth-bbc-1987.html#.U6L_LpRdXxA

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you so much for these recommendations!

    ReplyDelete