Wednesday, November 22, 2006

The Savoring of Books

A homeschool is like a recipe. Some of the ingredients are essential or the name of the recipe loses it meaning. For example, you can't have 'Potato Soup' without the potatoes. Then there are the minor ingredients. They add various flavors to it. I happen to like potato soup with cream and celery seed. You may prefer it with milk and thyme.

Our homeschool has major and minor ingredients. Some of the ingredients are just my particular preferences, or my children's preferences. It's our special flavoring. But as I reflected this week on the major ingredients of our homeschool, a concept came up that I realized was the potato in the soup. We need this ingredient in our school. It is a major contributor to the amount of learning my dc are experiencing and the level of joy we all are able to share together. It the SLOW READING of their school books. This may seem like a simple and minor ingredient. I hope to show that it is more important.

Years ago, when my children were young, we devoured several books a week. It was a point of pride for all of us. "Wow! I thought, my children must be learning a lot. They have covered so many ideas this year." My daughter could finish a book a day.

Then, I read this:

"We hear of 'three books a week' as a usual thing and rather a matter of pride. But this, again, comes of our tendency to depreciate knowledge, and to lose sight of its alimentary character. If we perceive that knowledge, like bread, is necessary food, we see also that it must be taken in set portions, fitly combined, duly served, and at due intervals, in order to induce the digestive processes without which, knowledge, like meat, gives us labour rather than strength." (vol. 5 of CM's educ. volumes)

Now, I probably would have never listened to such advice, but living in Turkey has its drawbacks. I had no library and no bookstore with books available in the English language. My children, out of necessity, were going to have to spread out their books. I could never keep the supply up with the demand. I decided to try this with their most important books, the books that I considered ' the cream of the crop', over a several week period. So, instead of reading a book or two a week and then going on to the next one, my children started several books at the same time but read them slowly over a 10 week period or longer.

I began to notice that my children were talking at the supper table about the characters and episodes in the books they were reading . They were acting out those stories with each other and including them in their playtimes. They even began to write their own stories, without my prompting, by copying the main idea and style of the book they were reading. Wow! My children were enjoying their books much more since they had time to ruminate and live with the characters and ideas expressed within the pages. Not only that, they remembered, and still remember years later, little details about those beloved stories. I realized that deep and lasting learning was taking place in a delightful, non-hurried manner.

If you'd like a better idea how this may look, you can visit my 13 and 11 yr old daughters' blog and look at the sidebar, you can see the titles and amount of books each girl is reading this term. They are reading all of these books each week but over several weeks. I've noticed that they are making posts about their books too. I do not direct those posts. They write about their books because they enjoy them.

If you are hesitant about trying this, maybe you could test it with just a few of your children's books this year and watch for interesting results.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

1 comments:

  1. previous commentors29.12.06

    November 22, 2006 - Thanks for the comment!

    Posted by deedeeuk

    I've been enjoying reading about CM in your posts. We are starting to move our homeschool closer to her style. We are doing this in baby steps rather than jumping in head first as some of it is drastically different to our current style. I guess we will get there eventually! Thanks for the encouragement!

    • Permanent Link • Edit • Delete

    November 22, 2006 - All books?

    Posted by Rhonda (209.144.248.209)

    Do your children read all their books this way, or just their books for school? I know that the Ambleside curriculum and your own has a list of "additional books" that do not necessarily seem to be tied to what is being studied. Should those be read at the same pace?



    November 22, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by lindafay

    Rhonda, Additional reading lists are read at the children's preferred pace. But most of their other school books are spread out.



    November 22, 2006 - Thank you for all of your posts

    Posted by Des

    I love reading your blog, but this post in particular spoke to me today. I had been having a conversation with myself about this very thing, spreading out my kids literature books. I'm finding that my DS is just not getting the time to read and get "involved" with his books the way I would like. I'm definitly going to work on slowing them down so that they can enjoy the books.



    November 22, 2006 - Impressed!

    Posted by

    You've given me something to think about. I had never heard of doing this before. I went to your children's site that you link to and was surprised. I had been to their site several times before. I usually stay away from children's blogs but I love The Lord of the Rings and am curently reading it. I'll have to say I am very impressed! A few days ago when I stumbled on their story that they are writing, I bookmarked it so I could go back an read it when I have more time.

    Edited by eclecticeducation on November 22, 2006 at 9:13 AM



    November 22, 2006 - A word at the right time

    Posted by HarmonyArtMom

    I know I told you already that I am thinking of using more CM in our homeschooling for high school and I was reading CM's view on the slow reading just last week. I have two readers who devour books and I think it would be the biggest leap for them to move to a slower pace. I have one that reads ahead as it is and I think he would have a harder time adjusting to this idea. I am willing to give it a try, especially after ordering the history books and seeing the size of them...they are huge for year 9, one of them having 1088 pages! I realize that he would actually only read around 200 pages for the year but he is the kind of child that would sit until the book was finished "just for fun". Do you have trouble with your children reading more than is assigned and if you do, how do you keep them to the schedule?

    I was wishing I could sit and talk to you about some of CM's ideas especially the idea that you can't just "add in a little CM" to your homeschool and think you are using her methods. I was reading in her book, can't remember which one now, how you really have to do it all or it isn't CM. Maybe you could talk about that sometime if you have any thoughts. You could also email me personally if you wanted to address it outside your blog. I am really falling off the Well Trained Mind bandwagon and am looking for something else, possibly CM for high school.

    Thanks for the thought-provoking entry again.
    Barb
    Harmony Art Mom
    harmonyfinearts@yahoo.com




    November 23, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by spunkyhomeschool

    I think it was Mortimer Adler in the book "How to read a book" that said, it's not how many books we get through, but how many get through to us. It does stop and make you think. Thanks for the post.



    November 23, 2006 - I might need some help with this...

    Posted by ThreeLittleLadies

    we are currently using Sonlight curriculum, and I must say we have a lot to read each day. I've been thinking about what pace CM would have used. Sometimes I think dd9's reading is a lot! It kinda takes the joy out of it for her too.



    November 24, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by sherrydhoneycutt

    I do like the sound of this idea. I think with my oldest (10) who reads several books a week, I will try this with some classics. She (unfortunately) reads a lot of twaddle. (I had not heard of CM until she was already 8 and by then already a voracious reader of mysteries and series books) So yes, classics is where we will start with this.

    Thanks so much for sharing!

    Sherry



    November 25, 2006 - It works!

    Posted by Lisa W.

    Hi Linda Fay,
    This is a wonderful post. I realized with my yougest son that he
    was reading so quickly, he was not digesting or retaining that which
    he read. Instead of giving a number of pages daily, I have given both
    of my sons 30 minutes per day in each of their school books. They
    have three hours per day for school reading, interspersed with copywork,
    music practice, math, scripture and memory work, etc. so they read six
    books per day. Since they are older, this is the perfect length of lesson
    time, too, so they do not lose interest before their subject changes.
    Usually they're begging to keep reading (but I say no, wait until tomorrow!) :o)
    Of course, as you said, their free reading time is their choice. This has
    also contributed to better-written narrations, as they truly can read slowly
    and remember that which they read in one thirty minute reading rather than in hours worth of reading in one subject area.



    November 25, 2006 - hi there!

    Posted by agodlyhomemaker

    i found your blog while surfing here and thought it would be interesting cuz we almost moved to turkey years ago. how funny when i found out that is where you are!! glad i found you!



    November 27, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by lindafay

    deedeeuk, I think baby steps are a good idea. As I became convinced of the validity and importance of each principle, I added one at a time to our school. I never felt overwhelmed this way. I believe I started with copywork; but before I did it, I researched it A LOT until I felt I understood how it should be done. I'm so glad I did it in this way. As in many of CM's principles, if copywork is applied incorrectly, the child will not learn as much and hate the exercise.

    Thanks for the kind words, Des and eclecticeducation. It will make my daughter's day, knowing that an adult is reading her story. She will often get up at 6am before the rest of the family just to work on that thing!

    Spunkyhomeschool, yes, I certainly agree with Mr. Adler. Quality over quantity. How to choose among the myriads available is a tough one for me. I simply don't have the time to read many books but I dearly love to read.

    Threelittleladies, I DO NOT like this about Sonlight. The books are raced through at a frantic pace. I DO love many of their book choices and think that it could be tweaked to be more CM friendly. I've ordered many books from them. I know that Sonlight is a great help to many families overseas. I have recommended it for mother's who are just stepping away from the textbook method. It is a nice hand holder and does so much work for the mother.

    Lisa W, thanks for sharing your success!
    Welcome, agodlyhomemaker. Thanks for commenting.
    Sherrydhoneycut, I do hope your daughter enjoys this method and learns more. I suspect she will be resistant at first, being used to something else. It may take a full year adjustment before older children are comfortable, but it pays off.





    November 27, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by lindafay

    Barb,
    I think that a homeschool can certainly add some of CM's ideas to it and make it a better experience for all. However, it will never be able to accomplish the goals and ideas that Miss Mason encouraged without fully implementing her ideas. Copywork, dictation and narration, for example, work hand in hand, complimenting each other. Some mothers do not see the expected results for grammar, handwriting or spelling after a few years of implementing CM ideas; but upon further inspection, we realize that the mother was not fully implementing the ideas and in the manner they should have been taught. It can not be hit and miss, or there most certainly will be weaknesses. Furthermore, if a mother decides to add these three concepts, but continues to allow her children to wolf books down rapidly, than less learning will take place, as well. Then we have the habit training dynamic. A CM education is IMPOSSIBLE without it. There are so many examples, I can't begin to name them all. As you read through Miss Mason's volumes and implement her ideas, you begin to discover how much they are interrelated.

    Miss Mason used a classical approach and this is especially evident in the later years although, I believe her classical ideas were implemented in a most wonderful, gentle, appealing manner in the early years, too. (being quite contrary to what is popular today among some classical circles.) I think the slow reading of books is very important in the later years. Also, narration is NOT just writing down summaries but encompasses far more in the high school years. I plan to write about this soon. Then we have nature study along with the formal sciences, art and music for enjoyment sake rather than mostly informational purposes. Language study, not just as a discipline, but to connect the student with the rest of the world. I think that implementing Miss Mason's ideas in the older years will add life and further enjoyment to a student's studies because she stressed the value of having purpose and ideas behind learning, rather than 'get knowledge.' The classical model today is in danger, I believe, of not truly being classical at all, but simply the getting of much knowledge. This is not what a classical education is about. I think parents are realizing this and are searching for ways to infuse life into it. Miss Mason offers such, imo.

    Okay, off my soapbox for now...

    If you have any more specific questions feel free to email me. I'll do my best to help.

    blessings,
    linda



    November 28, 2006 - copywork, etc.

    Posted by Debbie P.

    When you say you researched copywork before you implemented it- What exactly did you use to learn about it? I'm fairly sure I am not making full use of copywork, narration, and dictation with my children. Where would you suggest I begin to learn more about the proper use of these methods?
    Thanks :) You always make me think!



    November 28, 2006 - Untitled Comment

    Posted by lindafay

    Hi Debbie.

    I researched all over the internet, read several CM books, Ruth Beechick, Well trained mind et al. But the explanations of the method conflicted with one another. So, I finally went straight to the horse's mouth and read Miss Mason's Education volumes. I,3 and 6 speak the most about educational method. Vol 1 being for very young children; vol 3 for 9-12yr olds, and vol 6 being for older students (however, they all overlap). Her volumes are now available online and free in modern language so they are easier to read.

    By the way, Ruth Beechick and Sonlight's methods are not the same as Miss Mason's. I think this has confused many people. I don't think their methods are bad; they are just not applied in the way CM suggested and therefore, will have different results. I will not explain the differences here. I wouldn't want to do your thinking for you :- )

    You can also view my posts about the three subjects on my sidebar. Look under homeschool help. There are several educational categories. I believe I implement her method quite faithfully to what she proposed. Amblesideonline always has good help, too. If you have specific questions about the subjects and they have not already been covered on this blog, feel free to ask. If I can make it easier for anyone in any way, I will feel this blog is serving it's purpose.

    Warmly.

    ReplyDelete